Women's Suffrage in Massachusetts

A collection of unique documents from local collections highlighting diverging views and the evolution of the movement toward suffrage.

Detailed Timeline | Anti-Suffrage Documents | Related Websites and Articles

Image courtesy of the Library of Congress

Detailed Timeline
1780 Polly Welts Kaufman's Boston Women and City School Politics, 1872-1905 (New York: Garland, 1994) notes that the 1780 Massachsuetts State Constitution omits the word "male" as a qualification for elective office (but left as a qualification for voting).
1848 Women's Rights Convention held in Seneca Falls, NY.
1850 On October 23 & 24, the National Women's Rights Convention is held at Brinley Hall in Worcester, Massachusetts. Men and women from across the country are in attendance. Of the 268 names of those who signed-in, 186 were from Massachusetts (Harriet H. Robinson, Appendix D).
1866 The first meeting of the American Equal Rights Association is held at the Meionaon in Boston.

First petition to the Massachusetts Legislature, asking that women might be allowed to serve on school boards, is presented by Samuel E. Sewall of Boston. The same petition is presented again in 1867.
1868 New England Women's Club is founded at a convention at Horticultural Hall in Boston. By 1872 the New England Women's Club Standing Committee of Education states that "the most pressing business was securing the appointment of women on the school committee." Around this time women are elected to school committees in the small Massachusetts towns of Ashfield and Monroe. The cities of Lynn, Worcester and Boston are soon to follow.

An analysis of changes in the school committees of Beverly and Salem is presented in Kaitlin Nylund's Noblese Oblige, or Self Interest? A Demographic Analysis of School Committee Membership, Responsibility and Action, 1860-1900 (2002)

A history of the women's club movement, including the New England Women's Club, is described in Tara Talbot's The Lothrop Club and Its Contribution to the Women's Club Movement (2001).
1869 A joint special committee on Woman Suffrage is formed by the Massachusetts State Legislature. The State House of Representatives votes on the question of municipal suffrage for women: 68 "yeas" (33.8%) vs. 133 "nays".

The American Equal Rights Association changes the name of their organization to the National Women Suffrage Association. The American Woman Suffrage Association is also formed.
1870 The Massachusetts Woman Suffrage Association is formed at a meeting at Horticultural Hall in Boston.

The Woman's Journal: a Woman's Suffrage Newspaper is set-up by the New England Association in 1869 and in 1870. According to Harriet Robinson, "To sustain the Woman's Journal and furnish money for other suffrage work, two mammoth bazars [sic] or fairs were held in 1870 and 1871 in the Music Hall in Boston. Nearly all the New England Sates and many of the town in Massachusetts were represented by sale-tables in these bazars [sic]; and as usual donations were sent from all directions, and the women worked as women will work for a cause in which they are interested, to raise money to furnish the sinews of war. Many of them stood day after day behind sale-tables, or worked in the cafe as caterers and waiters. Women in whose veins ran some of the best blood in New England, did not hesitate even at that early date to become identified with the Woman Suffrage reform." (p. 64-65)

1871 In his address before the Massachusetts State Legislature, William Clafin becomes the first governor of the state to speak directly on the subject of women's rights. Clafin recommends a change in the laws regarding suffrage and property rights of women.
1874 Boston elects three women to serve on the school committee.
1879 The Massachusetts Legislature votes to allow women to vote for school committee members. At the first annual elections for School Committee about 5,000 women in Massachusetts became registered voters.
1879 Louisa May Alcott is the first woman to register to vote for the Concord School Committee election.
1880-1881 The next goal for the women's movement in Massachusetts is suffrage for municipal elections. For example in Beverly, a petition is brought before the town meeting "to see whether the Town will, by its vote or otherwise, ask the Legislature to extend to women who are citizens, the right to hold Town offices and to vote in Town affairs on the same terms as male citizens." These petitions are rejected by voters.
1881 Harriet H. Robinson's Massachusetts in the Women's Suffrage Movement: A General Political, Legal and Legislative History from 1774 to 1881 published in Boston.

Massachusetts State House of Representatives again votes on the question of municipal suffrage for women: 76 "yeas" (38.3%) vs. 122 "nays"
1892 In June, 1892, the poll tax for women in Massachusetts is abolished. This enables all women citizens of Massachusetts who can read and write the right to vote for local school committee members. The percentage of registered women voters continues to remain quite low. Women are only allowed to vote for school committee members until 1920. Many women feel that a broader franchise would encourage more women to vote. As Harriet H. Robinson writes in 1881, "If the law were really a 'school suffrage law' and included the question of school appropriations, school supervisors, ormanagement, the building of enormous and costly school houses, or even concerning the books their children were to use, the result might be different, and the women might become interested...In fact the School Committee question is not a vital one with either male or female voters, and it is impossible to get up any enthusiasm on the subject. As a test question upon which to try the desire of the women to become voters, it is a palpable sham." (Massachusetts in the Woman Suffrage Movement)

The Massachusetts School Suffrage Association surveys the number of women elected to school boards in Massachusetts. In addition to 4 in Boston, 157 women serve in 112 cities and towns.
1893-1894 Josephine St. Pierre Ruffin founds the Woman's Era Club for black women in Boston. Its motto is "Make the World Better". In 1895 the Woman's Era club publishes "The New Era" the first newspaper/magazine published for an by black women. Its readers are urged to become involved in public issues such as suffrage and civil rights.
1894 Although women are allowed to register and vote in school elections, not very many are signing up. There is a large disparity in the number of women versus men registered to vote in Beverly.
1895 Massachusetts holds a non-binding referendum concerning municipal suffrage for women. Although women are allowed to vote on this non-binding topic, the vote statewide is overwhelmingly rejected, as shown by example of Beverly's vote. Ninety-six percent of women vote in the affirmative (23,000 out of 24,000; there were 600,000 eligible women voters), versus only 32% of male voters (87,000 of 274,000).
1913
Beverly Beacon: A Woman's Newspaper (Beverly, MA) November 1, 1913. (HTML) (PDF)
The Beverly Beacon is an interesting presentation of the conditions and ideals of women in 1913 from a variety of perspectives. The editors of the paper describe it as "a paper with a purpose; two purposes, in fact. One is to throw light on our city, its past and present, its virtues and faults, and more particularly on the activities and opinions of its women." This is the only issue we know about; quite possibly it was the only one that was printed.
Contents:
Why Should We Shop in Beverly [advertisement]
The Women's Auxiliary of the Y.M.C.A. (S. Caroline Woodberry)
The Needs of Our Girls (Mary E. Bulkeley)
The First Sunday School Meeting in Our Country
Early Days of Beverly (Katherine P. Loring)
Poem (George E. Woodberry)
Lucy Larcom-A Memory (Mary Larcom Dow)
Walks About Beverly (Jenne A. Cole)
Editorial
Equal Suffrage (Anna C.M. Tillinghast)
Conclusions of an Anti-Suffragist (Caroline Atwater Mason)
Beverly Improvement Society (Bessie A. Baker)
Checking off the Laundry (A Beverly Householder)
The Lothrop Club
The Beverly Hospital (Louisa P. Loring)
What People Think About Some Things in Beverly (The People)
Nathaniel (Frances Sinnicks)
The Beverly Female Charitable Society (Sarah W. Clark)
Women's Work in the Churches
The Girls' Clubs of Beverly (Edith Preston)
Housework as an Art (Alice H. Ober)
Recipes Old and New

1915 Massachusetts males are asked to vote by referendum on women's suffrage as an amendment to the United States Constitution. As in 1895, the referendum is once again defeated by Massachusetts voters, reflected by the votes in Beverly. The only community in the state of Massachusetts to vote in favor of suffrage is Tewksbury with a vote of 149 to 148. Statewide, only 35.5% was in favor. Four states in the east vote on full suffrage for women: Massachusetts, New Jersey, Pennsylvania and New York. All four states vote in the negative.
1920 It is not until 1920 with the passing of the Nineteenth Amendment to the United States Constitution that women in Massachusetts were availed full voting privileges.

For more detail, read Jen Remare's Women Voters in Beverly, Massachusetts During the 1920 Election in Connection to the Woman's Suffrage Movement (1997)
Other Timelines:
Timeline from A History of the American Suffragist Movement (ABC-CLIO, 1997)
One Hundred Years toward Suffrage: An Overview (Library of Congress)

 

Anti-Suffrage Documents

Believe it or not, there was a strong anti-suffrage movement at the time led by women.

Anti-Suffragist Letter to Governor Coolidge (Courtesy of the Massachusetts Historical Society)

Anti-Suffragist Letter to Will H. Hays (Courtesy of the Massachusetts Historical Society)

Letter of Josephine Dodge of the National Association Opposed to Woman Suffrage (Courtesy of the Massachusetts Historical Society)

The Woman's Movement and Liquor Interests (Courtesy of the Massachusetts Historical Society)

The People's Verdict (Courtesy of the Massachusetts Historical Society)

The Woman's Protest Against Woman Suffrage (Courtesy of the Massachusetts Historical Society)

Johnson, Helen Kendrick. Woman and the Republic — a Survey of the Woman-Suffrage Movement in the United States (1897) (Project Gutenberg e-book)

Stevenson, Louise L. "Women Anti-Suffragists in the 1915 Massachusetts Campaign." The New England Quarterly, Vol. 52, No. 1 (Mar., 1979), pp. 80-93.

The Remonstrance Against Woman Suffrage (1909) (Library of Congress)
The Remonstrance
is published quarterly by the Massachusetts Association Opposed to the Further Extension of Suffrage to Women. It expresses the views of women in Massachusetts, Maine, Rhode Island, New York, Illinois, Iowa, Oregon, Washington, and other states who believe that the great majority of their sex do not want the ballot, and that to force it upon them would not only be an injustice to women, but would lessen their influence for good and imperil the community. The Remonstrants ask a thoughtful consideration of their views in the interest of fair discussion.

Related Websites and Articles

Boston Women's Heritage Trail

Teaching With Documents: Woman Suffrage and the 19th Amendment (National Archives)
Links to many other valuable documents, including petitions and photographs, at the National Archives.

Votes for Women: Selections from the National American Women's Suffrage Association Collection, 1848-1921 (Library of Congress)
The NAWSA Collection consists of 167 books, pamphlets and other artifacts documenting the suffrage campaign, including Harriet H. Robinson's Massachusetts in the Women Suffrage Movement: A General, Political, Legal and Legislative History from 1774 to 1881. This book, published in 1881, includes an excellent 88-page appendix of primary documents such as legislation, convention reports, first-hand accounts, and more.

Alice Stone Blackwell, "Objections Answered," 1915 (Douglass)
A pamphlet published in response to Anti-Suffrage sentiments.

Voters Deny Massachusetts Women the Right to Vote: November 2nd, 1915. (Mass Moments)

Massachusetts Woman Suffrage Association. Records in the Woman's Rights Collection, 1893-1918: A Finding Aid Guide to this collection in the Arthur and Elizabeth Schlesinger Library on the History of Women in America at Harvard University.